The short version
- The government is introducing a database of trusted traders and a milestone-based payment system to reduce risks associated with home renovations.
- Industry groups and opposition politicians criticize the voluntary nature of the scheme, arguing it will not deter fraudsters and may burden compliant businesses.
- Additional reforms include stricter regulations for private bailiffs in England and Wales to prevent intimidation and ensure professional standards.
The British government has announced a new initiative designed to shield homeowners from fraudulent tradespeople, introducing a database of verified contractors and a protected payment mechanism. Prime Minister Andy Burnham stated that unscrupulous operators cause significant stress for families by leaving projects unfinished or disappearing after receiving upfront payments. The administration argues that these rogue builders tarnish the reputation of honest professionals who work diligently to serve their clients.
Under the proposed scheme, which is scheduled to launch next month, participating traders must demonstrate adherence to specific standards regarding customer service, transparency, and dispute resolution. A key feature of the plan involves holding customers' funds in a secure account, releasing payments only after certain project milestones are successfully completed. This structure aims to prevent scenarios where consumers lose money due to overpriced costs, unfair practices, or outright theft by contractors who vanish before finishing the work.
The urgency of these measures is underscored by data indicating widespread dissatisfaction with home improvement services. Government figures suggest that more than a quarter of individuals who undertook renovations in the past eighteen months encountered problems. A survey conducted for the Competition and Markets Authority estimated that customers lost over £10 billion in 2024 due to losses, inflated pricing, or unfair treatment by traders. Citizens Advice has also identified home renovations as one of its primary sources of consumer complaints, highlighting the scale of the issue.
Despite the government's intentions, the National Federation of Builders (NFB) has expressed skepticism about the effectiveness of the new rules. Adas Rico Wojtulewicz-Richmond, the NFB's director of policy, argued that existing schemes already help consumers find trustworthy professionals and questioned whether this voluntary approach would actually stop bad actors from ripping people off. He suggested that a more effective solution would involve creating a project passport to record all work done, thereby raising industry standards and allowing consumers to identify companies with poor performance histories.
Political opposition has also criticized the announcement, focusing on the potential for increased bureaucracy. Shadow business secretary Andrew Griffith warned that the initiative risks piling unnecessary paperwork onto businesses that already operate legitimately. He argued that the government should instead focus on strengthening law enforcement and imposing tougher sentences for those who commit fraud, noting that rule-breakers will likely continue their activities regardless of the existence of a new app or database.
Liberal Democrat business spokesperson Sarah Olney described the announcement as half-baked, asserting that a voluntary code completely misses the mark. She emphasized that rogue operators are unlikely to sign up voluntarily and will simply continue to exploit families in the shadows. Olney stated that the current system is unfit for purpose and that the proposed changes fall short of fixing the real harm caused by fraudulent tradespeople who ruin lives every year.
In addition to targeting construction fraud, the government has unveiled plans to regulate private bailiffs in England and Wales. These changes aim to protect people in debt from intimidating behavior, unfair treatment, or being pushed into excessive repayment arrangements. Under the new framework, individuals facing enforcement action will have access to an independent complaints process, and private bailiffs will be required to adhere to higher professional standards.
Sarah Sackman, the minister for courts and legal services, acknowledged that while bailiffs perform an important function, their responsibility must come with high standards. The government also intends to examine how organizations like Trading Standards collaborate with regulators and enforcement bodies to ensure consumers are not passed from pillar to post. This follows revelations last year that understaffing in trading standards teams was contributing to an increase in scams and the sale of dangerous products.
Sources behind this briefing
Go to the original reporting
- BBC News↗'Cowboy builders' targeted in new government clampdown
