The short version
- Multiple police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service have admitted to significant failures in monitoring Simon Levy between his initial convictions and his arrest for murder.
- Two officers are currently under investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct regarding their handling of cases involving Levy, with two others moved to different roles due to incompetence.
- Victims' advocates and officials are calling for a comprehensive multi-agency review to address the lack of restrictions and monitoring that allowed Levy to continue offending.
British law enforcement agencies have formally acknowledged a series of critical failures in their supervision of Simon Levy, a serial sex offender who was recently convicted of murdering two women and raping another. The Metropolitan Police, British Transport Police, and the Crown Prosecution Service all conceded that their actions fell short of expected standards during the period between Levy’s first conviction for sexual assault in September 2021 and his arrest for murder in September 2025. This admission follows intense scrutiny over how authorities managed a known predator who was able to target victims repeatedly despite being under police watch.
Levy, aged 40, had previously been convicted of sexually assaulting two women in 2018, leading to his imprisonment in 2021. However, while on bail and subject to monitoring, he committed a violent rape in January 2025. He subsequently murdered Carmenza Valencia-Trujillo, 53, in March of that year, and Sheryl Wilkins, 39, five months later. In addition to these homicides, Levy was found guilty by a jury at Inner London Crown Court of groping ten women on the London Underground and an eleventh victim while he was incarcerated. These transport assaults occurred between October 2023 and May 2025, with the prison assault taking place in April 2022.
Andrea Simons, London’s victims’ commissioner, described a litany of failures that permitted Levy to operate with impunity. She emphasized the urgent need for a multi-agency review to determine why appropriate restrictions were not imposed and why monitoring was inadequate. Simons argued that public services must improve their ability to recognize patterns of offending before attackers become emboldened to escalate their violence. Her comments reflect broader concerns about systemic gaps in how high-risk offenders are managed across different jurisdictions and agencies.
The Independent Office for Police Conduct has confirmed that two officers are facing investigations into their conduct regarding the handling of Levy’s cases. A police constable is under investigation for gross misconduct, while a detective sergeant faces a misconduct inquiry. Additionally, British Transport Police stated that two other officers have been reassigned to different roles due to incompetence in investigating Levy’s assaults on public transport. These personnel actions underscore the severity of the operational errors identified in the case.
Lisa Ramsarran, the chief crown prosecutor for the Crown Prosecution Service, publicly apologized for the agency’s shortcomings, stating that their performance did not meet the standards owed to victims, families, and the public. The Metropolitan Police have stated that detectives have exhausted numerous lines of inquiry, including collaboration with coroners, to determine if Levy is responsible for other unsolved incidents or deaths. While no additional victims have been identified so far, authorities continue to urge anyone who believes they may have been attacked by Levy to come forward.
British Transport Police noted that more women may recognize Levy as their attacker but have not yet reported the incidents. They highlighted that Levy specifically sought out busy carriages on the Tube to assault passengers, a tactic that may have contributed to underreporting or delayed identification of victims. The force remains committed to identifying any further crimes linked to Levy, acknowledging that the full extent of his offending may not yet be known.
Advocates for victims’ rights have expressed outrage at the sequence of events. Lisa Squire, whose daughter was murdered by a man with a history of sex crimes, described the situation as a catalogue of disasters. She pointed out that clear warning signs and precursor offenses were ignored, suggesting that police could have intervened to prevent the murders. Her perspective highlights the emotional toll on families who see similar patterns of failure in how justice systems handle repeat offenders.
Zoë Billingham, a former independent police inspector known for advocating reforms in policing violence against women and girls, criticized the failure to connect the dots in Levy’s case. She noted that it was not merely one or two missed opportunities but an extraordinary succession of failures that allowed Levy to remain a threat to women and girls. Her analysis suggests that structural issues within law enforcement agencies need to be addressed to prevent similar tragedies in the future.
As investigations continue, the focus remains on understanding how such a high-risk individual was able to evade effective containment. The upcoming multi-agency review aims to provide answers regarding the lack of restrictions and monitoring failures. For now, the families of Levy’s victims and the wider public await accountability and concrete steps to ensure that similar lapses do not occur again in the handling of dangerous offenders.
The case has reignited debates about the effectiveness of current protocols for monitoring sex offenders on bail or released from prison. Critics argue that existing measures are insufficient to protect potential victims when clear patterns of predatory behavior emerge. The admissions by multiple agencies signal a recognition of these flaws, but the path toward meaningful reform remains uncertain as stakeholders call for stricter oversight and better coordination between different law enforcement bodies.
Sources behind this briefing
Go to the original reporting
- BBC News↗Levy victims urged to come forward as police accused of 'litany of failures'
