The short version
- A Pakistani court has awarded guardianship of Sara Sharif's five siblings to their paternal grandfather, concluding a prolonged custody dispute.
- The children, who have lived in Pakistan since August 2023, expressed comfort with the arrangement during court proceedings.
- Surrey County Council withdrew from the case earlier this year, citing an inability to pursue legal applications within the Pakistani judicial system.
A court in Pakistan has issued a final decision regarding the custody of the five siblings of Sara Sharif, granting guardianship to their paternal grandfather. This ruling resolves a complex and protracted legal battle that began after the children were brought to Pakistan in August 2023. The decision marks the end of years of uncertainty for the family, who have been caught between the judicial systems of the United Kingdom and Pakistan since the tragic death of their sister.
The five children, whose ages range from four to sixteen, have resided in Pakistan for over two years. They were initially placed in state care after being discovered by police at their grandfather’s home. The family had been in hiding for several weeks following the discovery of Sara’s body in Woking, Surrey. Her father, Urfan Sharif, and stepmother, Beinash Batool, subsequently returned to the United Kingdom where they were arrested at the airport.
In the UK, Sharif and Batool were convicted of murder after a trial revealed that Sara had been subjected to a two-year campaign of torture involving hooding, burning, and beatings. Sharif received a life sentence with a minimum term of forty years, while Batool was sentenced to life with a minimum of thirty-three years. The children’s uncle, Faisal Malik, who assisted in hiding the family, was found guilty of causing or allowing Sara’s death and received a sixteen-year prison term.
During the recent court hearing in Pakistan, all five siblings were asked to speak directly with the judge. The eldest child stated that they felt comfortable and settled in their current environment. When informed that their grandfather would officially become their guardian, the eldest responded positively to the news. This direct input from the children appears to have influenced the court’s final determination.
The legal struggle involved significant international coordination challenges. Surrey County Council had previously attempted to secure the return of the children through Pakistani courts. However, in June, the council withdrew from the case. Officials stated that they lacked the capacity to pursue the application effectively within Pakistan’s legal framework as English proceedings were drawing to a close.
The grandfather had been fighting for custody since October 2023, when he was initially granted temporary guardianship. He has emphasized that the children will retain their British citizenship. This status ensures that they have the option to return to the United Kingdom in the future if they choose to do so. The arrangement aims to provide stability while preserving their legal ties to both nations.
Education has been a priority for the older children during their stay in Pakistan. According to the grandfather, all siblings except the youngest are currently attending school. This continuity in education supports their integration into daily life in Pakistan. The final guardianship order solidifies this arrangement, providing a clear legal structure for their upbringing.
The case highlights the difficulties of cross-border child protection efforts. While the UK judicial system dealt with the criminal aspects of Sara’s death, the welfare of her siblings required navigation of Pakistani family law. The resolution allows the children to remain in a familiar environment under the care of a close relative, ending the period of state custody and legal limbo.
Moving forward, the focus shifts to the long-term well-being of the five children. With guardianship secured, they can continue their education and daily lives without the threat of forced relocation. The retention of British citizenship offers them flexibility regarding their future residency choices. This outcome provides a degree of closure for a case that captivated public attention in both countries.
The legal proceedings underscore the complexities involved when families are split across jurisdictions with differing legal standards. The court’s decision prioritizes the expressed wishes of the children and the stability provided by their grandfather. It concludes a chapter marked by tragedy and international legal maneuvering, allowing the siblings to move forward with a defined support system.
Sources behind this briefing
Go to the original reporting
- BBC News↗Sara Sharif's grandfather granted guardianship of her siblings in Pakistan
