The short version
- The BBC removed eleven sketches from the revived iPlayer collection of That Mitchell and Webb Look to align with contemporary cultural norms.
- Industry peers express mixed reactions, with some defending the creators' intent while others warn against excessive editorial caution in historical archives.
- This decision mirrors previous actions regarding Little Britain, reflecting a broader trend of re-evaluating older comedy content following social movements like Black Lives Matter.
The British Broadcasting Corporation has undertaken a significant curatorial adjustment to its digital archive by removing nearly a dozen comedy sketches from the revived iPlayer collection of That Mitchell and Webb Look. The decision comes as the Bafta-winning series, which originally aired between 2006 and 2010, returns to streaming platforms to mark its twentieth anniversary. Rather than presenting the complete original run, the broadcaster has opted for a selective approach, retaining only those segments it believes remain effective and appropriate for modern audiences.
A spokesperson for the BBC explained that the selection process involved consultation with the programme makers, David Mitchell and Robert Webb. The corporation stated that they included sketches that still work today while excluding those that do not. This editorial choice reflects a broader institutional effort to manage historical content in light of shifting social sensibilities. The removed material includes scenes that have drawn criticism for their portrayal of race, religion, and sexuality.
Reports indicate that the excised segments include a sketch featuring war re-enactors in blackface, a scene involving a contestant on a makeover show wearing a burka, and a segment depicting a tribe living in a garden centre. Other removed content reportedly includes a joke referencing Jimmy Savile and an impersonation of the late chef Gary Rhodes making homophobic remarks. These specific choices highlight the types of humor that the BBC now considers incompatible with its current broadcasting standards.
The reaction from within the comedy community has been nuanced, revealing a tension between artistic preservation and contemporary ethical guidelines. Dom Joly, known for Trigger Happy TV, questioned what he described as self-censorship by the corporation. He argued that while removing genuinely racist content is understandable, the intent of Mitchell and Webb was not to promote racism but to satirize it. Joly emphasized that the duo’s work should be viewed through the lens of its original critical purpose rather than solely through modern interpretive frameworks.
Conversely, Jimmy Mulville, co-founder of Hat Trick Productions, acknowledged the difficult position the BBC occupies. He noted that producers must exercise caution but warned against setting a precedent where historical content is routinely edited out. Mulville expressed concern that this could represent the beginning of a trend where more material is removed from circulation, potentially altering the cultural record. His comments underscore the anxiety among creators about the long-term availability of their work.
This incident is part of a larger pattern in British television regarding the handling of older comedy series. Matt Lucas and David Walliams’ Little Britain faced similar scrutiny, leading to its removal from iPlayer, Netflix, and BritBox in 2020. Objections at that time centered on characters portraying people from different ethnic backgrounds in ways that were deemed offensive. Both the BBC and BritBox cited changing times as the reason for the withdrawal, noting that standards have evolved since the show first aired in the early 2000s.
Little Britain has since returned to iPlayer, but like That Mitchell and Webb Look, it now exists in a curated form with certain sketches omitted. This parallel suggests a consistent strategy by the BBC to make older content accessible while mitigating potential backlash from segments that no longer align with current values. The Black Lives Matter movement has played a significant role in accelerating this re-evaluation, prompting broadcasters to reassess how historical media is presented to new audiences.
The implications of these decisions extend beyond individual shows, touching on broader questions about cultural memory and editorial responsibility. As institutions like the BBC navigate the complexities of digital archiving, they must balance respect for artistic legacy with sensitivity to contemporary social issues. The removal of these sketches does not erase the history of the programs but rather frames them within a specific interpretive context chosen by the broadcaster.
Looking ahead, the precedent set by these curatorial choices may influence how other classic series are handled on streaming platforms. Creators and producers will likely face increasing pressure to consider the long-term reception of their work, knowing that content can be edited or removed years after its initial broadcast. The BBC’s approach signals a shift toward proactive management of digital libraries, ensuring that archived material meets current ethical standards while remaining available for public consumption.
As the twentieth anniversary of That Mitchell and Webb Look unfolds, the debate over these removed sketches continues to resonate within the industry. The decision highlights the challenges of preserving cultural heritage in an era where social norms evolve rapidly. While some view the edits as necessary updates, others see them as potential losses to the artistic record. The outcome remains a point of contention, reflecting the ongoing negotiation between past creativity and present-day values.
Sources behind this briefing
Go to the original reporting
- BBC News↗BBC removes 11 Mitchell and Webb comedy sketches from iPlayer
